Back to Subject
Practice MCQ

Unit 2 - Notes

HRM203

Unit 2: HR Planning Process

1. HR Demand Forecasting

Human Resource Demand Forecasting is the process of estimating the future quantity and quality of people required. It involves determining the number of personnel needed for different job categories to achieve organizational goals within a specific timeframe.

Key Objectives

  • To quantify the jobs necessary for producing a given number of goods or offering a given amount of services.
  • To determine the nature of staff mix (skills, experience, and competencies) required.
  • To prevent shortages or surpluses of manpower.

Factors Affecting HR Demand

  1. External Factors:
    • Economic Conditions: Economic boom increases demand; recession decreases it.
    • Technological Changes: Automation may reduce demand for manual labor but increase demand for specialized tech skills.
    • Legal/Political Environment: Labor laws regarding working hours, retirement age, and safety.
    • Competition: Intense competition requires a more agile and skilled workforce.
  2. Internal Factors:
    • Organizational Strategy: Expansion, diversification, or downsizing strategies.
    • Budgetary Constraints: Financial resources available for hiring and training.
    • Production Estimates: projected sales and production volume directly dictate labor needs.
    • New Ventures/Projects: Specific timelines and skill requirements for new initiatives.

2. Quantitative and Qualitative Methods of HR Forecasting

HR forecasting techniques are broadly classified into two categories: Quantitative (Statistical) and Qualitative (Judgmental).

A. Quantitative Methods (Statistical Approaches)

These methods rely on historical data and mathematical formulas to predict future needs.

1. Trend Analysis

  • Concept: Analyzing past ratios (e.g., the ratio of production to workers) over the last 3–5 years to predict future needs.
  • Application: If the company has grown by 5% annually in workforce size, the planner assumes this trend will continue.
  • Limitation: Assumes the past is a perfect predictor of the future; does not account for sudden market disruptions.

2. Ratio Analysis

  • Concept: Calculating ratios between a specific business factor (e.g., sales volume) and the number of employees needed.
  • Example: If a salesperson generates 1,000,000, the firm needs 10 salespeople.
  • Formula:

3. Work-Load Analysis (Work Study Method)

  • Concept: Based on the total workload required to complete production targets.
  • Steps:
    1. Calculate total annual production.
    2. Determine standard man-hours required per unit.
    3. Calculate total man-hours required.
    4. Divide total man-hours by the number of working hours per employee per year.
  • Suitability: Best for manufacturing or operational roles where output is tangible.

4. Regression Analysis

  • Concept: A statistical method identifying the relationship between a dependent variable (manpower) and independent variables (sales, production, investment).
  • Application: Using software to draw a regression line to predict staffing levels based on changing independent variables.

5. Burks-Smith Model

  • Concept: An equation that calculates the required workforce based on the current level of business activity adjusted for turnover and growth.
  • Formula:
    • (Where is estimated demand, is business activity lag, is growth, is productivity improvement, is conversion factor).

B. Qualitative Methods (Judgmental Approaches)

These methods rely on the expertise, intuition, and experience of managers and experts.

1. Managerial Judgment

  • Bottom-Up Approach: Line managers estimate their department needs and send them to top management for consolidation.
  • Top-Down Approach: Top management creates a forecast based on strategic goals and distributes it to departments.
  • Participative Approach: A combination of both to reach a consensus.

2. Delphi Technique

  • Concept: A structured communication technique relying on a panel of experts.
  • Process:
    1. Experts are selected (usually anonymous to each other).
    2. Questionnaires regarding HR needs are distributed.
    3. Results are summarized and returned to experts for a second round.
    4. Process repeats until a consensus is reached.
  • Advantage: Eliminates bias caused by dominant personalities in face-to-face meetings.

3. Nominal Group Technique (NGT)

  • Concept: A face-to-face group meeting structure that encourages equal participation.
  • Process:
    1. Participants silently write down ideas/forecasts.
    2. Ideas are shared round-robin and recorded on a board.
    3. Group discusses to clarify ideas.
    4. Participants vote/rank the ideas to reach a decision.

3. Analysis of Manpower Supply

Once demand is forecasted, HR must analyze the supply—the availability of workers. This involves two sources: Internal Supply and External Supply.

A. Internal Supply Analysis

This assesses current employees who can be promoted, transferred, or retrained to fill future openings.

Key Tools for Internal Analysis:

  1. Skill Inventories (HRIS):

    • Detailed records of each employee’s education, experience, interests, and skills.
    • Used to identify "ready" candidates for open roles.

  2. Replacement Charts:

    • Visual representations of the organizational structure (similar to an org chart).
    • Indicates key positions and potential replacements, often color-coded (e.g., Green = Ready now, Yellow = Needs training, Red = No internal replacement).

  3. Markov Analysis (Transition Probability Matrix):

    • A mathematical method to track the pattern of employee movements through various jobs.
    • It calculates the probability of an employee remaining in a job, being promoted, demoted, transferring, or leaving the organization (exit).
    • Example: If historical data shows that 80% of Junior Analysts become Senior Analysts within 2 years, and 20% leave, this probability is applied to the current pool to predict future supply.

  4. Turnover Analysis:

    • Analyzing the rate at which employees leave (voluntary/involuntary). High turnover reduces internal supply reliability.

B. External Supply Analysis

If internal supply is insufficient, the organization looks to the external labor market.

Factors Influencing External Supply:

  • Demographics: Aging population vs. young workforce availability.
  • Unemployment Rate: High unemployment = easier/cheaper supply; Low unemployment = talent war.
  • Labor Market Conditions: Availability of specific skills in specific geographic regions.
  • Educational Output: The number of graduates entering the workforce with relevant degrees.
  • Immigration/Migration Laws: Ease of hiring foreign talent.

4. HR Planning Models

HR Planning models provide frameworks for integrating demand and supply to achieve organizational equilibrium.

1. The Gap Analysis Model (Matching Model)

This is the most fundamental model of HRP.

  • Step 1: Forecast HR Demand.
  • Step 2: Forecast HR Supply (Internal + External).
  • Step 3: Identify the Gap.
    • Surplus (Supply > Demand): Requires downsizing, layoffs, reduced hours, or early retirement schemes.
    • Shortage (Demand > Supply): Requires recruitment, overtime, outsourcing, or retraining.

2. The Systems Model (Input-Process-Output)

Views HRP as a subsystem of the larger organizational system.

  • Inputs: Corporate strategy, external environment, organizational culture, existing HR inventory.
  • Process: Analyzing manpower needs, analyzing supply, formulating plans (recruitment, training, redundancy plans).
  • Output: The Manpower Plan (staffing levels, budget, skill sets).
  • Feedback: Monitoring the effectiveness of the plan and adjusting inputs.

3. The Optimization Model

Uses linear programming and mathematical algorithms to determine the "optimal" mix of staff to minimize costs or maximize production, subject to constraints (budget, legal limits, space).

4. The Integrated Strategic HRP Model

This model emphasizes that HRP cannot function in isolation. It links HRP directly to the Business Lifecycle:

  • Start-up Phase: HRP focuses on attracting entrepreneurs and innovators.
  • Growth Phase: HRP focuses on rapid recruitment and formalizing policies.
  • Maturity Phase: HRP focuses on cost control and efficiency.
  • Decline Phase: HRP focuses on rightsizing and rationalization.

5. Challenges in HR Planning

Despite sophisticated methods, HR Planning faces significant hurdles.

1. Environmental Uncertainty (VUCA)

  • The business world is Volatile, Uncertain, Complex, and Ambiguous. Rapid technological shifts (e.g., AI) or global crises (e.g., pandemics) render long-term forecasts obsolete quickly.

2. Inaccuracy of Information

  • HRP depends on data (HRIS, performance records). If the internal data is outdated or external labor market data is unreliable, the forecast will be flawed ("Garbage In, Garbage Out").

3. Organizational Changes

  • Mergers, acquisitions, and restructuring can happen overnight, drastically changing labor requirements and making previous plans redundant.

4. Resistance to Change

  • Employees and trade unions often resist HRP initiatives, particularly if they involve workload analysis or rightsizing, fearing job losses or increased pressure.

5. Time and Cost Constraints

  • Comprehensive HRP (like Delphi technique or Regression analysis) is time-consuming and expensive. Smaller firms may lack the resources to conduct in-depth planning.

6. Lack of Top Management Support

  • If top management views HR as administrative rather than strategic, they may not share critical strategic plans with HR, leading to misalignment between business goals and talent planning.

7. Horizon Conflict

  • Balancing short-term operational needs (filling a vacancy today) with long-term strategic needs (developing leaders for 5 years from now) is difficult. Managers often prioritize the short term.